Erste Asset Management

ESG: Too much of a good thing?

ESG: Too much of a good thing?
ESG: Too much of a good thing?
Share post:

For a long time, the ESG sceptics could not really be heard in all the noise around the megatrend that sustainability has become in recent years across all sectors. There is hardly a corporate strategy in sight that does not bring up sustainability, hardly a lifestyle product that does not come with a planted tree pledge when you are buying it.

Megatrends tend to be put to the test after a while. This either puts an end to the trend or reinforces it by decluttering and focusing it. Hence, the headwind that ESG investments are currently faced with can also be read from a positive angle. But what are the main points of criticism?

1. Hypothesis: ESG is dying from its own success

In separate blog entries, my colleagues will be discussing a recently published, scientific paper in detail. For now, let me only describe its basic premise: due to the megatrend of sustainable investing, all investors are trying to buy those companies that are considered best from a sustainable (ESG) perspective. However, once all investors have bought the ESG pioneer for their portfolio, this company will not be able to record any gains any longer in the future because there are no buyers anymore. Since the stock exchange is a place of trading the future, this should push the return on brown (i.e. non-sustainable) investments above that on green (i.e. sustainable) investments.

In other words, has the outperformance in recent years been the exception, and will ESG investors earn a less significant performance in the future? The aforementioned premises are fortunately easy to rebut, and there is little need to worry:

  • THE undisputed model company that every sustainable investor wants to hold in their portfolio does not exist. Depending on the understanding of sustainability as held by the respective investment company, the global orientation, and the focus of the fund, different companies qualify as sustainable investment.
  • If certain companies have been identified by a sustainable investor as pioneer in the sector, they do not automatically keep this label for life but remain locked into ongoing competition. Today’s best can be tomorrow’s worst.
  • There will always be ESG sceptics, just as there are sceptics in other, well-researched areas. If the aforementioned paper had a lot of supporters, the investors following its rationale would prefer to buy brown investments (thinking erroneously that would earn them higher rates of return) and thus (ironically) refute the underlying assumption (i.e. all investors wish to buy sustainable investments).

2. Hypothesis: sustainable investors do not make the world a better place

In addition to science sceptics, we have also seen doubts from the sector itself in recent months. The former Head of Sustainability of one of the world’s biggest investment companies one day commented that the understanding of sustainability as embraced by his house did not come with any positive contribution for the world. Rather than investors exerting pressure on the specific companies, politicians should do so.

Who exerts pressure on whom?

The exchange between politicians and the economy is very important for the future of a country, as it determines jobs, tax revenues, competitiveness, and investments. The assumption that national governments can exert large amounts of pressure on global companies is just not in line with reality. In fact, if anything, there is pressure going the other way, not the least from various lobbying groups, which represent their sector interest in a bundled form. However, that is not necessarily also in the interest of long-term investors. For example, it may be profitable in the short run not to take any measures against climate change regionally. But in the long run this puts the innovative power and the international competitiveness at risk, if other countries decide on stricter measures that are then implemented successfully by the companies.

Sustainable investing works!

In order for the public statements of the oil sector not to be in diametric opposition to their private opinion, we have – in collaboration with other investors – successfully demanded transparency with respect to memberships and donations at lobbying groups.

This is one example of many where we managed to effect positive change as sustainable investment company. We document this annually in our public engagement and voting report. This way, you can check and hopefully come to the conclusion that sustainable investors do make the world a slightly better place.

ESG has not reached its destination yet, unfortunately

My colleagues and I are looking forward to the day when ESG has become irrelevant. This will be the day when climate change has been beaten and social grievances in companies have been done away with. It will still take a while though.

Legal note:
Prognoses are no reliable indicator for future performance.



Legal disclaimer

This document is an advertisement. Unless indicated otherwise, source: Erste Asset Management GmbH. The language of communication of the sales offices is German and the languages of communication of the Management Company also include English.

The prospectus for UCITS funds (including any amendments) is prepared and published in accordance with the provisions of the InvFG 2011 as amended. Information for Investors pursuant to § 21 AIFMG is prepared for the alternative investment funds (AIF) administered by Erste Asset Management GmbH pursuant to the provisions of the AIFMG in conjunction with the InvFG 2011.

The currently valid versions of the prospectus, the Information for Investors pursuant to § 21 AIFMG, and the key information document can be found on the website under “Mandatory publications” and can be obtained free of charge by interested investors at the offices of the Management Company and at the offices of the depositary bank. The exact date of the most recent publication of the prospectus, the languages in which the key information document is available, and any other locations where the documents can be obtained are indicated on the website A summary of the investor rights is available in German and English on the website and can also be obtained from the Management Company.

The Management Company can decide to suspend the provisions it has taken for the sale of unit certificates in other countries in accordance with the regulatory requirements.

Note: You are about to purchase a product that may be difficult to understand. We recommend that you read the indicated fund documents before making an investment decision. In addition to the locations listed above, you can obtain these documents free of charge at the offices of the referring Sparkassen bank and the offices of Erste Bank der oesterreichischen Sparkassen AG. You can also access these documents electronically at

N.B.: The performance scenarios listed in the key information document are based on a calculation method that is specified in an EU regulation. The future market development cannot be accurately predicted. The depicted performance scenarios merely present potential earnings, but are based on the earnings in the recent past. The actual earnings may be lower than indicated. Our analyses and conclusions are general in nature and do not take into account the individual characteristics of our investors in terms of earnings, taxation, experience and knowledge, investment objective, financial position, capacity for loss, and risk tolerance.

Please note: Past performance is not a reliable indicator of the future performance of a fund. Investments in securities entail risks in addition to the opportunities presented here. The value of units and their earnings can rise and fall. Changes in exchange rates can also have a positive or negative effect on the value of an investment. For this reason, you may receive less than your originally invested amount when you redeem your units. Persons who are interested in purchasing units in investment funds are advised to read the current fund prospectus(es) and the Information for Investors pursuant to § 21 AIFMG, especially the risk notices they contain, before making an investment decision. If the fund currency is different than the investor’s home currency, changes in the relevant exchange rate can positively or negatively influence the value of the investment and the amount of the costs associated with the fund in the home currency.

We are not permitted to directly or indirectly offer, sell, transfer, or deliver this financial product to natural or legal persons whose place of residence or domicile is located in a country where this is legally prohibited. In this case, we may not provide any product information, either.

Please consult the corresponding information in the fund prospectus and the Information for Investors pursuant to § 21 AIFMG for restrictions on the sale of the fund to American or Russian citizens.

It is expressly noted that this communication does not provide any investment recommendations, but only expresses our current market assessment. Thus, this communication is not a substitute for investment advice, does not take into account the legal regulations aimed at promoting the independence of financial analyses, and is not subject to a prohibition on trading following the distribution of financial analyses.

This document does not represent a sales activity of the Management Company and therefore may not be construed as an offer for the purchase or sale of financial or investment instruments.

Erste Asset Management GmbH is affiliated with the referring Sparkassen banks and Erste Bank.

Please also read the “Information about us and our securities services” published by your bank.

Subject to misprints and errors.

Leave a comment Required fields are marked with *

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *